« PMS: A CONFUSING SPRINGBOARD TO PREJUDICE | Main | WANNA PLAY? COME ON, PLEEAAAAASE? »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451f6e769e200d8342a298353ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference IS THERE A DOWN SIDE TO DRUGS THAT SUPPRESS MENSTRUATION?:

» The Ol' Visit from Aunt Flo (Or Not, as the Case May Be) from Stepping on Acorns
The Happy Feminist and others have been discussing new forms of the Pill that allow you to never have to menstruate. My first thought was, But I want to menstruate! Then I couldn't believe I thought that—at any other point [Read More]

Comments

Sara

I take a birth control pill that makes my period very gentle or occasionally nonexistant. Often, it'll be about 12 hours where I need to use a tampon and then I'm in the clear. It's kind of the best of both worlds - cramps aren't really an issue and I still get the reassurance that I'm not pregnant.

Omphale

Connie Willis had a fabulous short story called "Even the Queen" that imagines a world where no woman has to have her period. It's pretty damn funny, but also points out how incredibly freeing it is not to have to deal with these things...and has a subtle point in there about how motherhood becomes as active a choice as a career, because there are no accidents in this world.

Jess

Personally I hate my period, because it's painful and heavy and because I don't plan on having any more children anyway, so, really, what's the point?!

And let's face it, while menstruation is completely normal and natural, it's still a messy pain in the butt. I do think it's disgusting how these drugs are marketed, however, because this is about women's health and not about how much sex they're "able" to have.

I have a theory that most advertising agencies are run in secret by 13 year old boys.

Omphale

Back in my bad old days of debilatating cramps the thought I always had while lying on the floor clutching my bottle of Ibuprofen:

"I have to go through this every 26 days for thirtysome years because 6,000 years ago some dumb bitch ate an apple?"

And my father wonders why I don't go to church anymore.

Chalicechick

Thanks to the pill, mine is pretty light and only lasts a couple of days. If I'm not on the pill, I rarely have it at all.

But I don't want children, and I don't want to get rid of any either, and at the slightest weirdness in my stomach at any time of the month I start to worry, sometimes envisioning a tiny hand extending from my womb to wrap around the inside of my throat.

I take the pill responsibly and by package directions, but pills do fail. And I was an accident and the child of an accident so I was highly improbable in the first place.

Most months, I'm looking forward to the reassurance. But most of all, I look forward to menopause.

CC
aware she's sounding pathological, but that's the way it is.

The Happy Feminist

Sounds pretty sane to me!

Jess

I take hormone pills (skip the white pills) continuously to avoid my period as management of my endometriosis. Since it would be difficult for me to accurately differentiate between what positive effects are due to the control of the endo and which are due to the cessation of my periods, I won't try, but I can tell you this: I feel my mood changes are more my own, I don't miss the mess and definitely don't miss the cramping, vomiting and general misery that took a week or so out of my life every month before I started this treatment 4 years ago.

And I'm with you on the sex appeal issue, THF; as for things society tells women to do to be attractive, this one has some pretty significant personal benefits beyond the partner-related ones.

Terry

I wish they'd make something like this for menopausal women. I'm at the point where I have hot flashes and all the other meno. symptoms, but I still have periods. On an EXTREMELY irregular schedule. I don't think I should have to deal with both.

Amanda Marcotte

I really am uncomfortable with the implications that supressing your period so you can have sex more is "for" men at the expense of women. I said this at Alas. Sex on your period isn't fun for women, so I don't see why supressing it wouldn't be to our benefit as well.

The Happy Feminist

I think that is a really important point. My comment had to do with the way it would likely be marketed -- and possible pressure on women to go for the more convenient sex in order to please the menfolk even if the woman herself might otherwise prefer to forego the potential long term risks of menstruation suppressents.

The comments to this entry are closed.